Replacing Windows – Keep Your Criteria to Three

August 26, 2015

Share this Article:

A red pool ball with the number three on it.

To broaden your chance of selecting the right replacement window, narrow your criteria.

 Choosing the right replacement window can be an overwhelming task because of the seemingly limitless options available today. If you focus on only three criteria, you’ll triple your chance of choosing successfully. The three essential criteria to weigh are, your window budget, the window U-factor and the window warranty – everything else is ancillary.

How much do you want to spend?  

It’s common when asked, what is your budget for replacing your windows most people try to skirt the question, because they think it will prematurely eliminate options. Replacement windows can range from inexpensive windows at around $150-400 all the way up to $750-1000 per window. The reality is that when it comes to replacement windows knowing what you want to spend per window is the best place to start. Price narrows the material choices, wood, fiberglass, composite or vinyl. In a nutshell, wood windows will be the most expensive and if you want stain options, you’ll add additional costs. Fiberglass windows look like wood and will also be in the higher price range. Composites usually cost less than Fiberglass and promise similar durability. If you want a less expensive window you can select from a range of vinyl options.

A house with a lot of windows is surrounded by trees and bushes

 Vinyl windows may not be as durable as the other three options, but if you select the best vinyl windows you’ll have a better product. Window manufacturers offer a range of products and within a particular product category; such as vinyl, they will offer lower end lines and high quality lines. The upper end lines typically have lifetime warranties, better U-factors, higher quality weather stripping and extrusions. 

What is the U-Factor?  

One of the primary reasons to replace your old windows is to realize the benefits of more energy efficient window technologies. How well the window insulates is measured by how much heat transfers from the inside to the outside, this is the U-factor.

Connect with Us:

A dining room with a table and chairs and a chandelier.
October 2, 2026
Single-hung and double-hung windows look very similar but have important differences that affect the way they function and how they’re maintained.
Worker carrying window panes beside a beige house under renovation
September 23, 2026
Discover which window brands Chicago-area contractors prefer, including Marvin, Andersen, Infinity by Marvin, and Quaker, and how to choose the right products for your project.
Snowy suburban house with brick and stone exterior, gabled rooflines, and red ladders set up on the front facade.
September 21, 2026
Discover which windows perform best in Midwest winters, including U-factor, glass, frame materials, air leakage, installation, and Low-E options.
More Posts